Smart speakers tested

A preference of intelligent speakers

Image caption

Amazon’s Alexa executive Daren Gill has called voice “the subsequent good interface”

For a final 4 weeks, I’ve been vital in an Orwellian nightmare. One in that we have to watch any word we contend given “they” are always listening. And by “they”, we meant Alexa, Siri and Google.

It seemed like a good thought – get 7 intelligent speakers and exam them in a genuine residence to see how they influenced a listening habits and daily routine.

At times, they’ve been flattering helpful. If we’re using low on biscuits, one of us can bark, “Hey Siri, supplement Hob Nobs to a selling list” and a sign appears on a phones.

During Storm Emma, Google kept me present on sight cancellations, while a kids amused themselves for hours by seeking Alexa what sound a cat makes.

Thankfully, nothing of a inclination started spontaneously shouting in a center of a night – nonetheless they were all disposed to bouts of madness.

I once asked Alexa “what’s a continue in Yemen” and got a reply: “‘Das wetter’ is German for ‘the weather’.”

And when we told Google to “play strain in a kitchen”, it responded by streaming Lee Brice’s Songs In The Kitchen to a orator in a dining room (congratulations, Lee, on your new kingship stream).

Skip Youtube post by Lee Brice

End of Youtube post by Lee Brice

Youtube post by Lee Brice: Lee Brice - Songs In The KitchenImage Copyright Lee Brice
Lee Brice

To find out that intelligent partner was a smartest, we put any of a speakers to a exam – posing 50 pointless questions on music, competition and ubiquitous knowledge. Like all good ask uncover hosts, we usually supposed their initial answer.

Alexa fared best, with 37 scold answers, followed by Google on 32, and Siri, that scored a squalid 27.

Apple’s partner was hobbled by a skip of formation with other apps – definition it couldn’t examination my calendar or demeanour adult recipes.

When it came to music-related queries, however, Siri had some-more success.

For instance, a HomePod was a usually orator that could parse a authority “play a James Bond thesis next”. Its competitors all attempted to find a strain called “James Bond Theme Next”, failed, and gave up.

You can find a full list of questions, and how a speakers responded, here.

None of them are ideal (never ask for strain by Haim in a Northern Irish accent) nonetheless intelligent speakers demeanour set to reinstate a smartphone as a tech giants’ biggest expansion products.

Choosing a right one can be tricky. So here’s a lamp to a speakers, and how they competence fit into your lifestyle.

Apple HomePod (£319)

Image copyright

Apple has arrived late to a intelligent orator market, nonetheless not by laziness.

The HomePod has been in growth given 2012, and boasts an radical pattern – with 7 tweeters (the speakers that furnish treble) organised in a round to plan strain into any indentation and corner of your house. The drum is also punchy and well-balanced, even during low volumes.

I found it worked improved with acoustic, singer-songwriter material. Playing Regina Spektor’s Samson, a HomePod championed a singer’s vocals nonetheless losing a fact in her piano work. On a busier strain like Stevie Wonder’s Superstition, however, it struggled to collect out a star’s perplexing drumming.

It’s also an impossibly unrelenting orator – perfectionist your courtesy with a unequivocally “forward” soundstage. We found that was good in a dispatch and discord of a family kitchen, nonetheless reduction appealing when listening to strain in bed during night.

One critical note: You can’t set adult a HomePod unless we have an iPhone or an iPad. The orator is afterwards tethered to that device and certain functions, like updating your selling list, usually work when they can “see” any other.

HomePod is also totally constant to Apple Music. You can’t ask Siri to tide from Spotify or Deezer – nonetheless we can entrance them on your phone and lamp them to a speaker.

Best for: Apple enthusiasts; audiophiles

Amazon Echo Plus (£139)

Image copyright

If we wish a orator that comes with a giveaway light bulb, afterwards Amazon’s Echo Plus is your usually choice.

The orator aims to be a “home hub”, determining all sorts of connected devices, from your lights to your kettle. we wasn’t means to exam those abilities, though, as a BBC bill didn’t widen to shopping me remote control curtains.

As a strain player, a Echo Plus is efficient nonetheless unspectacular – nonetheless it’d make an ideal deputy for a kitchen radio.

Alexa will happily tide from Spotify and Deezer, as good as Amazon’s possess Music Unlimited use – that we get during a bonus if we squeeze an Echo device.

It’s utterly good during anticipating a strain we want, even if we have a terrible memory. we managed to get Alexa to evidence adult Girls Aloud’s Love Machine by asking, “What’s a strain that goes, ‘Let’s go, Eskimo?'”

One word of warning: Amazon’s streaming use doesn’t have a parental filter, so you’re stranded with a pithy versions of a songs in their catalogue.

And now that Amazon has leased Alexa to other orator manufacturers, there are improved inclination in a identical cost range.

Best for: Casual listening, intelligent partner abilities

Ultimate Ears Megablast (£199)

Image copyright
Ultimate Ears

The Megablast is a long, high cylinder of fun, accessible in a operation of colours (our examination section was a pale yellow, that we became weirdly lustful of).

It gives out a bassy, fulsome sound; that goes adult really, unequivocally shrill nonetheless losing any finesse. You can use Alexa to play songs from Amazon Music Unlimited (but not Spotify yet), or simply use it as a bluetooth orator to tide strain directly from your phone.

Best of all, we can unplug it and take it to a party, with a inexhaustible battery life that means we won’t be left discordant when a time strikes midnight. And it’s waterproof, so it won’t go kaput if we brief your drink.

On a downside, a microphone is bad during picking adult your voice commands – generally when strain is playing. And a charging pier is awkwardly placed during a bottom of a speaker, definition it has to be laid on a side when a plugged in, ruining a sound. (Ultimate Ears sells a apart charging dock, graphic above, for £35 if this is a deal-breaker).

Best for: Portability, volume

Sonos: One (£199)

Image copyright

Sonos are masters of multi-room audio, nonetheless a One is their initial incursion into intelligent orator territory.

There’s an intriguing set-up, where you’re asked to call your phone around a room while a section emits a array of sci-fi bleeps and bloops.

This helps a orator adjust to a sourroundings and, to be fair, it achieved superbly in a cluttered bedroom, with a weighty, energetic smoothness that belied a small size.

Superstition, that astonished Apple’s HomePod, sounded splendid and lively, with a deep, musty drum and copiousness of respirating room for Stevie Wonder’s vocals.

Best of all, Sonos welcomes all strain streaming services – with 49 now accessible in a UK, including Apple Music (not all of them can be tranquil by Alexa, though).

You can also sequence dual Sonos speakers together to get stereo, while a Sonos app is a usually one that allows we to tweak settings like three-way and drum to tailor a strain to your tastes. And if we buy mixed units, we can shock your family by personification spook noises in a integument while you’re in a kitchen.

One tiny niggle: Sonos has automatic Alexa to pronounce over a start of your music, so we constantly skip a initial 5 seconds of your favourite album.

Best for: Stereo, choice of streaming services, multi-room audio

Google Home (£129)

Image copyright

It looks like an atmosphere freshener. An atmosphere freshener on a Starship Enterprise, nonetheless an atmosphere freshener nonetheless.

Still, we was utterly enamoured with a Home’s sleek, matte white finish and a easygoing, accessible voice of a practical assistant.

It transpires that her discourse was created by Emma Coats, a former Pixar worker who drew adult a film studio’s 22 manners of storytelling – that explains because Google feels some-more enchanting than a competitors.

There are a few neat touches to a AI, too. When we ask Google to “flip a coin”, for example, we hear a sound of a silver being tossed before training a result. Even better, a Google Home enables we to make voice calls to any UK landline or mobile series – for free.

Sadly, though, a device isn’t adult to most as an tangible speaker. It had a misfortune sound of all a units we tested, and was disposed to twisted drum even during low volumes.

Best for: Personality, design

JBL Link 300 (£249)

Image copyright
Harmon Kardon

Luckily, fans of Google’s voice partner have some alternatives. Sonos are earnest a Google-enabled orator after this year and JBL will recover their Link 300 in a subsequent integrate of weeks.

It’s a corpulent small device that works best on cocktail and hip-hop, with an expressive sound that emphasises a low finish interjection to a round resonator on a behind that pumps out a bass.

One neat underline is a wi-fi light that shows a strength of your internet tie (something I’d like to see on some-more devices, given a sketchy wi-fi in a house).

In a end, this became a go-to orator in a vital room and kitchen, notwithstanding an annoying five-minute quarrel to make it play a Hamilton soundtrack.

It turns out we had to contend “OK Google, play ‘Hamilton: Original Broadway Cast Recording'” – a authority that’s as discerning as a lead wetsuit.

Best for: Google smarts with improved sound.

Amazon Echo Show (£199)

Image copyright

The Echo Show has a 7-inch screen, that displays strain lyrics while we listen. It’s a bit of a gimmick, nonetheless it was a large strike with a kids.

The device also came in accessible in a kitchen, where we used it to arrangement recipes and set timers nonetheless carrying to hold a shade with a gummy fingers.

All this functionality comes during a cost of sound quality, though. Don’t design anything over your normal time radio.

Best for: Karaoke night

Secret choice eight: Don’t buy any of them

Image copyright
Getty Images

Here’s a thing: With a probable difference of Sonos: One, you’re not removing loyal hi-fi sound with any of these devices.

If you’ve already got a good home stereo, it’s most cheaper to buy an Amazon Echo Dot (currently £39) and offshoot it adult to your existent set-up with a elementary cable.

Similarly, if you’ve got £300 to spend, we can get a decent hi-fi complement and an Echo Dot with income to spare.

That way, we get all a advantages of voice control and strain streaming nonetheless violation a bank.

Best for: People who’ve already got speakers and have remoteness concerns about this whole thing.

Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram during bbcnewsents. If we have a story idea email

Rate this article!
Smart speakers tested,5 / 5 ( 1votes )