No FA Cup replays = no party?

Ryan Giggs scores opposite Arsenal in a 1999 FA Cup semi-final replay during Villa Park

Media playback is not upheld on this device

7 good moments in FA Cup replays

A universe though FA Cup replays? Seriously?

The Football Association and Premier League clubs are mulling over either a oldest domestic football foe should be done into a midweek eventuality – with no replays.

It would apparently revoke tie congestion, presumably assist clubs in European foe and even assistance a particular inhabitant teams.

But FA Cup replays have supposing so many good moments in years left by. So suppose if we never had replays.


Ryan Giggs v Arsenal – 1999 semi-final replay

Ball is given divided by Vieira, Giggs pounces, surges down a left, past one, past two, past 3 challenges… GIGGS!

It is one of a biggest goals in FA Cup vital memory. Manchester United wing consternation Ryan Giggs led his side to a 2-1 win in extra-time, after a initial compare had finished 0-0.

But what if a opening competition had been staid on penalties?

Yes, there would be no Gunners suspense of Dennis Bergkamp blank a chastisement in a failing seconds of normal time, though there would also be no Giggs idea and his twirling of a United shirt and baring of a hairy chest.

In fact, had he not scored that ‘worldie’ would he be remembered as a… well… a Nani?

Ronnie Radford v Newcastle – 1972 third-round replay


Media playback is not upheld on this device

Top 50 FA Cup goals: Hereford favourite Ronnie Radford’s famous strike

“Radford again, OHHH! WHAT A GOAL! WHAT A GOAL!”

BBC commentator John Motson shrieked those famous difference during Edgar Street 44 years ago. Little did he know it would turn a shave that is arguably a many played of any other in FA Cup history.

The victims of this giant-slaying were Newcastle; a 2-1 victors were non-league Hereford, and favourite of a 35-yarder? Ronnie Radford, a joiner.

In terms of ‘magic’ of a crater this was like magicians Dynamo and David Copperfield fasten army to make Old Trafford disappear.

Had a compare been motionless after a 2-2 during St James’ Park, it would have deprived a football universe of one of a biggest ‘David beats Goliath’ stories and denied Radford one heck of an anecdote.

Cambridge United during Manchester United – 2015 fourth-round replay


Media playback is not upheld on this device

Manchester United 3-0 Cambridge United

It was not about a result. Cambridge mislaid 3-0.

It was a fact a League Two side, who cost about £0, hold United during Abbey Stadium and had a choice of a replay during one of football’s good stadiums.

There was a combined reward of additional TV income and income from embankment profits – an estimated £1m – a win, win, win situation.

They even gave United – whose starting XI cost £231m – an early scare. Had striker Tom Elliott scored he would have been this millennium’s Ronnie Radford.

Everton 4-4 Liverpool – 1991 fifth-round replay


Media playback is not upheld on this device

FA Cup archive: Everton 4-4 Liverpool, 1991 fifth-round replay

Those were days when English football could not get adequate of replays – Leeds and Arsenal played any other 4 times for a place in a fifth turn that same season.

This was a tie that had dual replays. The initial compare finished 0-0 during Anfield before Everton hosted a red half during Goodison Park.

Those who attended substantially still speak about a compare currently – a 4-4 rather than a 0-0.

Liverpool took a lead 4 times usually to be pegged behind on any arise – crucially in a 89th notation when Tony Cottee poked in to make it 3-3, and thereafter in a 114th notation when a petite striker steady a trick.

The Toffees won a third compare 1-0. In between a dual replays, Kenny Dalglish quiescent as Reds manager.

It was a brief though thespian duration in a story of a dual Merseyside teams.

Angelo Ogbonna v Liverpool – 2016 fourth-round replay


Media playback is not upheld on this device

FA Cup: Angelo Ogbonna heads West Ham leader during death

Tension, excitement, 39 efforts on goal, an doubtful match-winner – we had it all.

We were seconds from a dreaded penalties. But with 121 mins on a clock, former Juventus defender Angelo Ogbonna leapt adult with rocket fuel in his boots to conduct in – evidence derangement and bubbles.

It was a stirring encounter, to quote mechanism diversion Football Manager, where both teams “threw counsel to a wind”.

So given a choice between that outcome or a 0-0 in a initial compare followed by penalties?

We all know a answer.

‘Won 8-2 after additional time. Bonkers.’

We asked Sportsday readers for their best FA Cup replay moments and here are some of a responses:

Matt Parry: Dan Gosling’s final notation leader for Everton in a replay opposite Liverpool in 2009. Missed it means a broadcaster went to adverts.

Andrew Conquest: Leyton Orient v Droylsden in 2010. 2-0 down. Four sendings off. Two players scored a shawl trick. Won 8-2 after additional time. Bonkers.

Lee: Norwich City 0-1 Charlton Athletic in 2009. Abject. Protests outward Carrow Road afterwards. Manager Glenn Roeder sacked a subsequent morning.

Stu Tench: Gordon Armstrong’s injury-time leader for Sunderland v Chelsea in a quarter-final replay during Roker in 92. Roy of a Rovers stuff.

AC Brook: Best replay memories? Both for West Ham, opposite Everton final deteriorate 9-8 on penalties and Liverpool this season.

Hesham: It has to be Spurs v Manchester City in 1981 and Ricky Villa scoring a best ever idea in a final.

Rate this article!